Insurance News

Insurers Need Tech, Communication Focus

Posted on: October 6, 2009

Insurance companies need to work on communications with agents and beef up their technology, according to more than 1,200 agents polled by state trade groups.

The findings came in the 2009 Company Performance Survey, administered by the Professional Insurance Agents of Connecticut, New Hampshire, New Jersey and New York State Inc.

Their survey announcement included listings of the top three insurers favored by each state group.

According to the survey, agents said companies do well on the fundamentals, like claims handling and underwriting.

?It?s reassuring to find that insurance companies are doing so well where it matters most to independent agents,? said Diane Fowler, executive director of PIACT, PIANH, PIANJ and PIANY.

?Companies are demonstrating sound, consistent underwriting and paying client claims promptly and fairly; it?s great to see carriers excelling in precisely the areas our members deem important,? added Ms. Fowler.

The PIA?s Company Performance Survey gauges insurance producers? views of their carriers and gives independent agents the opportunity to share opinions on their companies? handling of claims; products and pricing; technology; underwriting, and more.

PIA said it added something this year by comparing the survey data against the findings of PIA?s Company Benchmark Survey, which gave agents the opportunity to rate the most important factors when deciding whether or not to work with a carrier.

Agents named claims handling and underwriting as the two most important criteria by which they judge a company?s value. ?The findings made a lot of sense,? said Kevin M. Ryan, CIC, PIANY president. ?After all, the smoother the claims process, the quicker agents can help their clients.?

Also for the first time this year, PIA said it is offering PIA member companies detailed reports covering not only their performance scores but also their agents? comments and how well they fare against other carriers on the top-10 benchmark factors agents value most.

?Each year, we?re contacted by more and more company representatives, requesting inclusion in the survey or information on the results. Clearly, the findings are incredibly valuable to company representatives,? said William R. Vowteras, PIANJ president.

PIA said performance ratings and comments show numerous ways companies lose out when they fail to communicate with agents as equal partners.

In the one underwriting area (flexibility) in which performance scores are below average, ?too many companies seem unwilling to explore the opportunities a risk presents, using agents? firsthand input, and figuring out a way to accept it. Even in today?s soft market, underwriting flexibility and appetite was the topic mentioned most often, when agents named what commercial-lines units need to work on,? the organization said.

For personal lines, agents said companies need to work most on pricing.

?Companies have a real opportunity to stand out from the rest of the pack if they concentrate on their partnership skills,? said James A. Goodman, PIACT president. ?Effective two-way communication opens the doors to more production.?

PIA found uneven company response is evident in other areas as well.

The association said a ?surprising number? of agent comments centered on call-backs or return e-mails from certain carriers.

Resolving issues quickly is among agents? highest priorities when judging a company?but on average, companies score only so-so, PIA noted.

Some carriers said the organizations just don?t demonstrate what one agent calls ?that sense of urgency,? whether it?s underwriter response time or customer service. Some also seem slow to act on their agents? ear-to-the-ground market advice.

A final way companies can differentiate themselves is technology, which received the lowest average score in the 2009 survey, PIA reported.

It also figured large in comments, especially agents calling for improvement. One agent, stating what a specific company needs to improve, replied: ?Automation?absolutely, absolutely critical for survival and growth.?

Mr.Goodman said, ?Agents do business where transactions prove easy and efficient. That?s why each year?s survey lets agents provide current, detailed feedback to their carriers on several technology-related items.?

After rating each individual carrier from 20 separate standpoints, agents were prompted to name the company?s greatest strength and something they would like to see improve.

In their comments, PIA said agents tended to focus on sales-related features like rating technology, products, pricing and underwriting flexibility. Technology comments, for example, overwhelmingly cite the companies? rating systems, with 44 percent identifying rating technology as a company?s greatest asset, while 56 percent picked it as the thing they want a company improve.

?It?s strictly business when agents have to name a company?s one main strength,? said Stanley H. Pollack, PIANH president. ?And, when we?re asked for one item we?d like to see fixed, we?ll focus on what we need to make the sale. After looking at companies from all sides, it comes down to this: Can we write business with them, or not??

PIA said 1,226 agents responded to the survey evaluating an average of 5.7 insurers each, resulting in more than 7,000 total individual evaluations.

The top three scorers in Connecticut include Travelers (commercial), Vermont Mutual and Chubb (personal). New Hampshire?s top three are MMG Insurance Co., Concord Group and Vermont Mutual.

PIANH is scheduled to present awards to several of the highest-scoring companies at its Fall Education Festival, Oct. 8 in Concord, N.H.

New Jersey?s top three: ACE/Atlantic Mutual (personal), ARI and Chubb (personal). New York?s top three: Sterling Insurance Co., Erie Insurance Group and New York Central Mutual.

In addition to the individual reports available on request to PIA member companies, PIA member agents may request information on performance of companies they represent, and the October editions of the associations? PIA magazine contain state-specific results, including the top-performing companies for each of the survey?s 20 items.

© Copyright 2009 National Underwriter Property & Casualty. A Summit Business Media publication. All Rights Reserved.

Divining Agent PreferencesNAMIC Testifies at Wisconsin Insurance Department Hearing on Credit-based Insurance Scores


%d bloggers like this: